I just bought Augusten Burroughs’ newest memoir, A Wolf at the Table and have been avidly reading it the past week. I also convinced my boyfriend to watchRunning With Scissors with me (somehow). But both these Burroughs experiences are leaving me a little… dissatisfied.
I loved the book Running With Scissors. And the movie? Eh. It was okay. Annette Bening was incredible (the scene in the kitchen on Augusten’s birthday was horrifying and amazing at the same time). But other than that, I wasn’t too sure how much I liked it. It’s hard to watch the-movie-based-on-the-book and notcompare it to the book. The story was a little different, that’s fine; I understand it’s an adaptation of the book (something Harry Potter fans don’t seem to understand), but I just felt like the movie was missing something. Like it was disjointed. And not in a good, artistic-way like some movies. The charming thing about the book was how honest it was; it was unbelievable, but it was true! The movie felt like a P.C., bleached-clean version of the book. And the ending! Ugh. No mention of anything else that happened in his life, like Burroughs just turned out peachy-keen after that whole ordeal and happened to write a book about it. But you (or I) know that’s wrong! Look at the rest of Running With Scissors, look at Dry! The ending felt fake. No one gets off that easy - and Burroughs didn’t either, but it isn’t mentioned.
As for A Wolf at the Table, its tone is wonderfully child-like. The things that young Augusten talks about and believes and does seem so perfectly fitting for a kid in that situation. The way he wants affection and attention from his dad and never gets it is sad in so many ways: sad because you remember being a kid and feeling that way, or sad because, as an adult, you hate his father for neglect, or sad because the whole situation is so unhealthy and he’s just a child. But, as far as memoirs and books about dysfunctional families go, I think that Running With Scissors beats A Wolf at the Table hands down. (And Dry beats them both.) So far it hasn’t made a huge impression on me. I guess it’s hard for a child to have to kind of epiphanies and experiences and understanding that someone older (even 16-year-old Augusten from Scissors) can, so I am left wondering where and how this is exactly going to end. I thought the later chapters of the book would reveal an adult-Augusten searching for answers, but thus far, it is nothing but child-Augusten. Not that that’s bad; I’m just waiting for the big climax of the memoir. Or for something to happen that will make the whole book come full circle.
I’ll have to dig Dry out of my bookcase or all the boxes of books I have and re-read it. I still remember bawling my eyes out when Pighead died, and being mad at Augusten for drinking, and when he picked up the broach from the jeweler’s. That’s the kind of overwhelming sadness I expected from the movie and A Wolf at the Table. But maybe not every part of Burroughs’ life has to be packed with a seemingly-unbelievable amount of sadness. So I guess that’s a good thing, right?